The most hyped game of the weekend, Colts versus Patriots, lived up to its BILL-ing, partly due to coach Bill Belichick’s controversial decision that may have cost the Patriots more than just this game. Leading by 6 points, facing 4th and 2 at their own 28 with just 2:08 left in the game, Belichick decided his team’s best chance to win the game was to go for the first down. The Patriots weren’t able to convert and Peyton Manning, working with a short field, hooked up with Reggie Wayne on a slant route for a game winning touchdown with just 13 seconds left to go, that capped a 17-point fourth quarter comeback for Manning and the Colts.

Tom Brady can't hide his disappointment
I think you can credibly argue that Belichick’s decision to go for the first down versus punting in that situation cost the Patriots the game. However, I think you can also argue that his decision put his team in the best position to win the game.
Traditional football wisdom says you punt the ball and make the Colts go the 60-70 yards to beat you. Yet, with Peyton Manning in charge of an offense that was rolling, Belichick decided to do what he thought gave his team the best chance to win. We can all argue whether it was the right decision, but the reality is, Belichick is a genius if the Patriots convert. In my opinion, the odds of Peyton Manning leading the Colts down the field to victory with 2 minutes and 3 timeouts left is somewhere north of 70%, no matter where they’re on the field.
If the Patriots were my favorite team in that situation I would have wanted them to punt BUT I understand what Belichick was thinking. Whether or not the right decision was made is totally dependent on the outcome and thus Belichick is under fire for his decision because Tom Brady and the Patriots failed to convert.
Long-Term Implications
The long-term implications of this one decision may reverberate within New England’s organization for quite some time, or it may not have any impact at all. I’m not a Belichick apologist at all, in fact I think he’s an asshole who deserves more criticism for illegally taping opponents during the teams Super Bowl years but he did what he thought gave his team the best chance to win.
How this will impact the Patriots will play out over the course of the season. The big news here that is getting over looked, is that the Patriots, with a recent team history of making plays to put teams away, couldn’t put the Colts away and now find themselves with almost no chance at all of getting a home game against the Colts in the playoffs.
Hottie Watch – despite not being able to convert on the last play, Tom Brady had a good game going 29 of 42 for 375 yards with 3 TDs and 1 INT.
Next up for Indianapolis, a road game versus the inconsistent Ravens while the Patriots return home with a chance to avenge an earlier season loss to Mark Sanchez and the Jets.